{ "contradictions": [ { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:29:00Z", "edge_type": "REFUTES", "id": "edge_64700d6da6744362", "rationale": "Compile the immutable original source with pinned Lean 4.19.0; retain exit 1 and the elaboration error.", "run_id": "", "source_atom_id": "atom_b74beaff2e044d8f", "target_atom_id": "original_lean_compiles", "weight": 1 }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:28:57Z", "edge_type": "REFUTES", "id": "edge_1fa2b12009f44717", "rationale": "Replay exact arithmetic or exhaustive digital action pairs; preserve both observations.", "run_id": "", "source_atom_id": "atom_e0a3ada7028f4045", "target_atom_id": "nominal_winner_robust", "weight": 1 }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:28:54Z", "edge_type": "REFUTES", "id": "edge_478bcd8cfa3d45b1", "rationale": "Replay exact arithmetic or exhaustive digital action pairs; preserve both observations.", "run_id": "", "source_atom_id": "atom_727d6f1b647f40fd", "target_atom_id": "digital_ablation_safe", "weight": 1 }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:28:50Z", "edge_type": "REFUTES", "id": "edge_98466b33ea554406", "rationale": "Replay exact arithmetic or exhaustive digital action pairs; preserve both observations.", "run_id": "", "source_atom_id": "atom_29b01f19192e436b", "target_atom_id": "raw_sensor_safe", "weight": 1 }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:23:31Z", "edge_type": "REFUTES", "id": "edge_1b9e03c1f97240ab", "rationale": "Exact counterexample replay under the benchmark's default envelope.", "run_id": "", "source_atom_id": "atom_dfe2a077f1ac4711", "target_atom_id": "short_test_suffices", "weight": 1 } ], "frontier": [ { "atom_id": "atom_b1f637235b874de4", "content": "Test invariant corner cases, gain 5 near-miss, raw observer distinction, and compile all-time invariant with arbitrary natural t.", "next_action": "retrieve similar failures and decide whether to refine, refute, or promote", "priority": 2.8, "status": "UNDER_TEST", "tags": [ "refutation" ], "type": "RISK" }, { "atom_id": "atom_6739535690954b3d", "content": "Reject tampered cost 56, infeasible (7,1), and nonoptimal (8,0); independently enumerate every objective-bounded cheaper candidate; compile the global natural-number lower-bound theorem.", "next_action": "retrieve similar failures and decide whether to refine, refute, or promote", "priority": 2.8, "status": "UNDER_TEST", "tags": [ "refutation" ], "type": "RISK" }, { "atom_id": "atom_90c3e60d8d06425e", "content": "Generate the smallest witness that falsifies: Prove the real-valued bounded scalar thermal recurrence refines the existing natural-number ceiling envelope, then use strict quantizer margin to prove all-time observation equality.", "next_action": "test equivalence or find a counterexample", "priority": 2.46, "status": "CANDIDATE", "tags": [ "counterexample_search", "morph" ], "type": "REFORMULATION" }, { "atom_id": "atom_609932bd31964d02", "content": "Restate as an explicit iff/contract: Prove the real-valued bounded scalar thermal recurrence refines the existing natural-number ceiling envelope, then use strict quantizer margin to prove all-time observation equality.", "next_action": "test equivalence or find a counterexample", "priority": 2.35, "status": "CANDIDATE", "tags": [ "equivalent_statement", "morph" ], "type": "REFORMULATION" }, { "atom_id": "retrieval_prior_art", "content": "Two TheoremSearch queries returned adjacent or low-signal results, none selected as a premise; the formal graph query timed out. Morph suggestions remained generic untrusted proposals. No formal-corpus coverage or new theorem is claimed.", "next_action": "retrieve similar failures and decide whether to refine, refute, or promote", "priority": 2, "status": "CANDIDATE", "tags": [], "type": "RESULT" }, { "atom_id": "physical_refinement", "content": "Prove the real-valued recurrence refines the integer envelope under explicit initialization, load, disturbance, rounding, and observation assumptions; preserve threshold strictness.", "next_action": "morph into testable hypotheses", "priority": 2, "status": "CANDIDATE", "tags": [], "type": "QUESTION" }, { "atom_id": "observer_inventory", "content": "Validate a complete deployment-specific observer and actuator inventory, aggregate colluding-worker bounds, and measured conservative hardware envelopes.", "next_action": "morph into testable hypotheses", "priority": 2, "status": "CANDIDATE", "tags": [], "type": "QUESTION" }, { "atom_id": "model_contract", "content": "The benchmark declares five digital controls; rho<=9/10, |u|<=1, |w|<=1/1000; mediated threshold 55/1000; s,r nonnegative integers; cost s^2+2r^2 and service 100-5r. These are illustrative premises, not measurements.", "next_action": "retrieve similar failures and decide whether to refine, refute, or promote", "priority": 2, "status": "CANDIDATE", "tags": [], "type": "RESULT" }, { "atom_id": "concrete_gate", "content": "Refine the concrete bounded input parser, verifier, canonical release and total fallback to the abstract theorem, including worst-case public deadline and resource effects.", "next_action": "morph into testable hypotheses", "priority": 2, "status": "CANDIDATE", "tags": [], "type": "QUESTION" }, { "atom_id": "claim_inflation", "content": "A model result, passing Lean build, short trace, or Research Kernel SUPPORTED label could be misreported as physical containment, universal AI alignment, or OpenAI endorsement.", "next_action": "retrieve similar failures and decide whether to refine, refute, or promote", "priority": 2, "status": "CANDIDATE", "tags": [], "type": "RISK" } ], "graph": { "atoms": [ { "artifact_refs": [ "CONTRACTS.md", "MATH.md", "Proofs.lean", "results.json", "sha256:3719a1d940bc3b5b3bd8405e8f237228d8360152f9c1c1458c3bf8cc8942ef05", "sha256:c7fac7d4d6ddd4ad8b9e6bffac4e83b996d6d04b7a50ac8b3721a2e5d42e560b" ], "confidence": null, "content": "Under the declared integer model with 2s+r>=16 and r<=4, all feasible designs cost at least 57, attained by s=7,r=2. Falsifier: a feasible pair with cost<57, invalid identity coefficients, or failed Lean theorem.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:17:28Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:1807b0b8569010a2ac1fc23b220fefcb1bf95abc865b65464519a04d10b36072", "id": "optimal_cost", "importance_score": 0.5, "metadata": { "publication_scope": "bounded illustrative research", "replay_recipe": "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab; bash check_lean.sh" }, "normalized_content": "under the declared integer model with 2s+r>=16 and r<=4, all feasible designs cost at least 57, attained by s=7,r=2. falsifier: a feasible pair with cost<57, invalid identity coefficients, or failed lean theorem.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.5, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [ "https://github.com/TheDarkLightX/CovertChannelLab/blob/main/evidence/publication/verification.json" ], "status": "SUPPORTED", "tags": [ "covert-channel-lab", "negative-knowledge", "publication" ], "type": "CLAIM", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:35:34Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [ "CONTRACTS.md", "MATH.md", "Proofs.lean", "results.json", "sha256:3719a1d940bc3b5b3bd8405e8f237228d8360152f9c1c1458c3bf8cc8942ef05", "sha256:c7fac7d4d6ddd4ad8b9e6bffac4e83b996d6d04b7a50ac8b3721a2e5d42e560b" ], "confidence": null, "content": "For all natural t, the stipulated integer envelope at s=7,r=2 stays below 55. Falsifier: any recurrence step violating M<=50 or a failed winning_envelope_forever theorem. Real-plant refinement is a separate open obligation.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:17:32Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:9e042af7824abf904447003150f04e0d3f1ea5c29386b3164cc5e94f2fd05d19", "id": "integer_envelope", "importance_score": 0.5, "metadata": { "publication_scope": "bounded illustrative research", "replay_recipe": "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab; bash check_lean.sh" }, "normalized_content": "for all natural t, the stipulated integer envelope at s=7,r=2 stays below 55. falsifier: any recurrence step violating m<=50 or a failed winning_envelope_forever theorem. real-plant refinement is a separate open obligation.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.5, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [ "https://github.com/TheDarkLightX/CovertChannelLab/blob/main/Proofs.lean" ], "status": "SUPPORTED", "tags": [ "covert-channel-lab", "negative-knowledge", "publication" ], "type": "CLAIM", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:35:38Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [ "CONTRACTS.md", "MATH.md", "Proofs.lean", "results.json", "sha256:5faba2d40d54ddb5fc6219d947cf3357f4499d04d67cc63c95bae775c955f8bf" ], "confidence": null, "content": "For the default s=7,r=1 setting, identical observations for the first 23 steps imply all-time identical observations.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:17:35Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:217229595c2619247beeee75fd4f10cc55ff77364ea88cebc9720ab1c1c3bd4a", "id": "short_test_suffices", "importance_score": 0.5, "metadata": { "publication_scope": "bounded illustrative research", "replay_recipe": "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab; bash check_lean.sh" }, "normalized_content": "for the default s=7,r=1 setting, identical observations for the first 23 steps imply all-time identical observations.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.5, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [ "https://github.com/TheDarkLightX/CovertChannelLab/blob/main/research/negative-knowledge.json" ], "status": "REFUTED", "tags": [ "covert-channel-lab", "negative-knowledge", "publication" ], "type": "HYPOTHESIS", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:48Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [ "CONTRACTS.md", "MATH.md", "Proofs.lean", "results.json", "sha256:61c1878e806b6ed2c160a820d3a44552216f34bc55dfb7dee08f963e5c1a1fd5" ], "confidence": null, "content": "For the default s=7,r=2 setting, the receiver can observe raw temperatures without distinguishing u=0 from u=1 under common disturbance.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:17:38Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:3aafea5df0b272f3136ea2b715be53abab8a328107cad07f9b943eb7f24de962", "id": "raw_sensor_safe", "importance_score": 0.5, "metadata": { "publication_scope": "bounded illustrative research", "replay_recipe": "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab; bash check_lean.sh" }, "normalized_content": "for the default s=7,r=2 setting, the receiver can observe raw temperatures without distinguishing u=0 from u=1 under common disturbance.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.5, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [ "https://github.com/TheDarkLightX/CovertChannelLab/blob/main/research/negative-knowledge.json" ], "status": "REFUTED", "tags": [ "covert-channel-lab", "negative-knowledge", "publication" ], "type": "HYPOTHESIS", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:52Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [ "CONTRACTS.md", "MATH.md", "Proofs.lean", "results.json", "sha256:20fac2eb8c82d3ea54537909be6cbd0ed539db9d3ba317f99cea5af601f73267" ], "confidence": null, "content": "Within the five-control model, at least one digital control can be removed while preserving observations for every untrusted action.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:17:41Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:fabcff14e0362b2db67a7ad778280bf141917501db345356d25ffba1c1e900d9", "id": "digital_ablation_safe", "importance_score": 0.5, "metadata": { "publication_scope": "bounded illustrative research", "replay_recipe": "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab; bash check_lean.sh" }, "normalized_content": "within the five-control model, at least one digital control can be removed while preserving observations for every untrusted action.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.5, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [ "https://github.com/TheDarkLightX/CovertChannelLab/blob/main/research/negative-knowledge.json" ], "status": "REFUTED", "tags": [ "covert-channel-lab", "negative-knowledge", "publication" ], "type": "HYPOTHESIS", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:56Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [ "CONTRACTS.md", "MATH.md", "Proofs.lean", "results.json", "sha256:800bb7000f2323bc34e0ee25d9fcef774e66e338841e3b02ae6874025edfff46" ], "confidence": null, "content": "The nominal s=7,r=2 invariant certificate remains valid when the disturbance doubles, load bound doubles, or rho increases to 0.92.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:17:44Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:99f614563771cd03b092543b35f0b2d6c45b1eae4314cb5087308b3250ff5cdf", "id": "nominal_winner_robust", "importance_score": 0.5, "metadata": { "publication_scope": "bounded illustrative research", "replay_recipe": "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab; bash check_lean.sh" }, "normalized_content": "the nominal s=7,r=2 invariant certificate remains valid when the disturbance doubles, load bound doubles, or rho increases to 0.92.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.5, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [ "https://github.com/TheDarkLightX/CovertChannelLab/blob/main/research/negative-knowledge.json" ], "status": "REFUTED", "tags": [ "covert-channel-lab", "negative-knowledge", "publication" ], "type": "HYPOTHESIS", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:59Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [ "CONTRACTS.md", "MATH.md", "Proofs.lean", "results.json", "sha256:72ebcbe72baaf6fd9896625ac7af14b0ebef6f0f436311215f222ac090aab31c" ], "confidence": null, "content": "The unmodified Proofs.lean in the original archive compiles successfully under pinned Lean 4.19.0.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:17:48Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:acf187ddc8ccf72df9491e5a96dd7393e4c43e0fc4857908e92d75a4c0eeb073", "id": "original_lean_compiles", "importance_score": 0.5, "metadata": { "publication_scope": "bounded illustrative research", "replay_recipe": "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab; bash check_lean.sh" }, "normalized_content": "the unmodified proofs.lean in the original archive compiles successfully under pinned lean 4.19.0.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.5, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [ "https://github.com/TheDarkLightX/CovertChannelLab/blob/main/research/negative-knowledge.json" ], "status": "REFUTED", "tags": [ "covert-channel-lab", "negative-knowledge", "publication" ], "type": "HYPOTHESIS", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:35:02Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [ "CONTRACTS.md", "MATH.md" ], "confidence": null, "content": "The benchmark declares five digital controls; rho<=9/10, |u|<=1, |w|<=1/1000; mediated threshold 55/1000; s,r nonnegative integers; cost s^2+2r^2 and service 100-5r. These are illustrative premises, not measurements.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:19:42Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:c780031021f838508ebfbcd3b9fc91e9fc71b1d73c3af5d2010c66d0287e3fca", "id": "model_contract", "importance_score": 0.5, "metadata": { "interpretation": "declared model premise" }, "normalized_content": "the benchmark declares five digital controls; rho<=9/10, |u|<=1, |w|<=1/1000; mediated threshold 55/1000; s,r nonnegative integers; cost s^2+2r^2 and service 100-5r. these are illustrative premises, not measurements.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.5, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [], "status": "CANDIDATE", "tags": [], "type": "RESULT", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:19:42Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [ "CONTRACTS.md", "MATH.md" ], "confidence": null, "content": "Prove the real-valued recurrence refines the integer envelope under explicit initialization, load, disturbance, rounding, and observation assumptions; preserve threshold strictness.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:19:46Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:c99a5a4ce4d02b7a2bb0e130720ec65a586b73223bf165545684d3a4af6fc2e5", "id": "physical_refinement", "importance_score": 0.5, "metadata": { "interpretation": "open research obligation" }, "normalized_content": "prove the real-valued recurrence refines the integer envelope under explicit initialization, load, disturbance, rounding, and observation assumptions; preserve threshold strictness.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.5, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [], "status": "CANDIDATE", "tags": [], "type": "QUESTION", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:19:46Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [ "CONTRACTS.md", "MATH.md" ], "confidence": null, "content": "Refine the concrete bounded input parser, verifier, canonical release and total fallback to the abstract theorem, including worst-case public deadline and resource effects.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:19:49Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:e1858513923ed40cfde0dc7cf998265fba42d1888bc385e0bc9a17a8586b5bd0", "id": "concrete_gate", "importance_score": 0.5, "metadata": { "interpretation": "open research obligation" }, "normalized_content": "refine the concrete bounded input parser, verifier, canonical release and total fallback to the abstract theorem, including worst-case public deadline and resource effects.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.5, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [], "status": "CANDIDATE", "tags": [], "type": "QUESTION", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:19:49Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [ "CONTRACTS.md", "MATH.md" ], "confidence": null, "content": "Validate a complete deployment-specific observer and actuator inventory, aggregate colluding-worker bounds, and measured conservative hardware envelopes.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:19:52Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:d57cd1923862da600aefaefab01675a3c48fbcc461f61f39da26d550f4a70d8c", "id": "observer_inventory", "importance_score": 0.5, "metadata": { "interpretation": "open research obligation" }, "normalized_content": "validate a complete deployment-specific observer and actuator inventory, aggregate colluding-worker bounds, and measured conservative hardware envelopes.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.5, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [], "status": "CANDIDATE", "tags": [], "type": "QUESTION", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:19:52Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [ "CONTRACTS.md", "MATH.md" ], "confidence": null, "content": "A model result, passing Lean build, short trace, or Research Kernel SUPPORTED label could be misreported as physical containment, universal AI alignment, or OpenAI endorsement.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:19:54Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:fda623f8c1a86f5dbcfb8a67e68109674218f5de6306e41d401769af4b867f5f", "id": "claim_inflation", "importance_score": 0.5, "metadata": { "interpretation": "unresolved risk" }, "normalized_content": "a model result, passing lean build, short trace, or research kernel supported label could be misreported as physical containment, universal ai alignment, or openai endorsement.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.5, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [], "status": "CANDIDATE", "tags": [], "type": "RISK", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:19:54Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [], "confidence": null, "content": "Restate as an explicit iff/contract: Prove the real-valued bounded scalar thermal recurrence refines the existing natural-number ceiling envelope, then use strict quantizer margin to prove all-time observation equality.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:19:54Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:06d34c7a7dc377a5d3a976c6dcebfce3da3241e44670915706812849a37c01a1", "id": "atom_609932bd31964d02", "importance_score": 0.55, "metadata": { "relation_to_original": "equivalent", "risk": "check semantic preservation" }, "normalized_content": "restate as an explicit iff/contract: prove the real-valued bounded scalar thermal recurrence refines the existing natural-number ceiling envelope, then use strict quantizer margin to prove all-time observation equality.", "novelty_score": 0.6, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.7, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [], "status": "CANDIDATE", "tags": [ "equivalent_statement", "morph" ], "type": "REFORMULATION", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:19:54Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [], "confidence": null, "content": "Generate the smallest witness that falsifies: Prove the real-valued bounded scalar thermal recurrence refines the existing natural-number ceiling envelope, then use strict quantizer margin to prove all-time observation equality.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:19:54Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:c351dc805185aaec433c30cc3276620c8e3708e9397ea8b88faab8983289110e", "id": "atom_90c3e60d8d06425e", "importance_score": 0.66, "metadata": { "relation_to_original": "speculative", "risk": "may change problem meaning" }, "normalized_content": "generate the smallest witness that falsifies: prove the real-valued bounded scalar thermal recurrence refines the existing natural-number ceiling envelope, then use strict quantizer margin to prove all-time observation equality.", "novelty_score": 0.6, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.7, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [], "status": "CANDIDATE", "tags": [ "counterexample_search", "morph" ], "type": "REFORMULATION", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:19:54Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [], "confidence": null, "content": "{\"first_different_step\":24,\"zero_trace\":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0],\"hot_trace\":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,1],\"zero_temperature\":\"920233556923127490136639/100000000000000000000000000\",\"hot_temperature\":\"2760700670769382470409917/50000000000000000000000000\",\"common_disturbance\":\"1/1000\"}", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:23:31Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:9dd8ca2e865c681c0cfb0e2c282ce044e6574980754c2649b4dcfb7b6e2b8d4d", "id": "atom_dfe2a077f1ac4711", "importance_score": 0.8, "metadata": { "actual_counterexample": true, "evidence": "research/negative-knowledge.json", "lesson": "Use an all-time invariant. This near-miss first diverges at step 24.", "record_id": "NK-01", "strategy": "Exact counterexample replay under the benchmark's default envelope.", "tests": [ "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.ThermalTests.test_near_miss_at_24_not_23" ] }, "normalized_content": "{\"first_different_step\":24,\"zero_trace\":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0],\"hot_trace\":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,1],\"zero_temperature\":\"920233556923127490136639/100000000000000000000000000\",\"hot_temperature\":\"2760700670769382470409917/50000000000000000000000000\",\"common_disturbance\":\"1/1000\"}", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 1, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [], "status": "REFUTED", "tags": [ "refutation" ], "type": "COUNTEREXAMPLE", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:23:31Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [], "confidence": null, "content": "Reject tampered cost 56, infeasible (7,1), and nonoptimal (8,0); independently enumerate every objective-bounded cheaper candidate; compile the global natural-number lower-bound theorem.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:23:38Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:22046a905d8329118ee434b3c81d544107d85c8e8bb47b93cc561536ca8f4b20", "id": "atom_6739535690954b3d", "importance_score": 0.8, "metadata": { "actual_counterexample": false, "result": "No counterexample found; universal scope comes from the checked Lean theorem, not the bounded search.", "strategy": "Reject tampered cost 56, infeasible (7,1), and nonoptimal (8,0); independently enumerate every objective-bounded cheaper candidate; compile the global natural-number lower-bound theorem.", "tests": [ "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.OptimizationTests", "bash check_lean.sh" ] }, "normalized_content": "reject tampered cost 56, infeasible (7,1), and nonoptimal (8,0); independently enumerate every objective-bounded cheaper candidate; compile the global natural-number lower-bound theorem.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 1, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [], "status": "UNDER_TEST", "tags": [ "refutation" ], "type": "RISK", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:23:38Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [], "confidence": null, "content": "[{\"id\":\"NK-02\",\"claim_id\":\"raw_sensor_safe\",\"outcome\":\"REFUTED\",\"title\":\"Raw sensors defeat the observation restriction\",\"rejected_claim\":\"The winner makes raw hot and quiet temperatures indistinguishable.\",\"witness\":{\"s\":7,\"r\":2,\"step\":1,\"quiet_temperature\":\"1/1000\",\"hot_temperature\":\"1/200\",\"quantized_observations\":[0,0]},\"lesson\":\"The guarantee depends on a mediated quantized observer; raw trajectories differ.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.ThermalTests.test_quantization_is_essential\"}]", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:28:50Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:7728f1f2b382ebac2e5614581b04e3ba109f7e04b6976b406b21def8b4c96847", "id": "atom_29b01f19192e436b", "importance_score": 0.8, "metadata": { "actual_counterexample": true, "strategy": "Replay exact arithmetic or exhaustive digital action pairs; preserve both observations.", "tests": [ "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.ThermalTests.test_quantization_is_essential" ] }, "normalized_content": "[{\"id\":\"nk-02\",\"claim_id\":\"raw_sensor_safe\",\"outcome\":\"refuted\",\"title\":\"raw sensors defeat the observation restriction\",\"rejected_claim\":\"the winner makes raw hot and quiet temperatures indistinguishable.\",\"witness\":{\"s\":7,\"r\":2,\"step\":1,\"quiet_temperature\":\"1/1000\",\"hot_temperature\":\"1/200\",\"quantized_observations\":[0,0]},\"lesson\":\"the guarantee depends on a mediated quantized observer; raw trajectories differ.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.thermaltests.test_quantization_is_essential\"}]", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 1, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [], "status": "REFUTED", "tags": [ "refutation" ], "type": "COUNTEREXAMPLE", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:28:50Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [], "confidence": null, "content": "[{\"id\":\"NK-03\",\"claim_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"outcome\":\"REFUTED\",\"title\":\"Removing canonical encoding\",\"rejected_claim\":\"Dropping canonical_encoding preserves observation equality.\",\"witness\":{\"actions\":[{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false},{\"variant\":true,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":true,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false}],\"observations\":[{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0},{\"payload\":[17,1],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0}]},\"lesson\":\"Retain this control or discharge its exact observation obligation.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.DigitalTests.test_five_ablation_witnesses\"},{\"id\":\"NK-04\",\"claim_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"outcome\":\"REFUTED\",\"title\":\"Removing fixed release slot\",\"rejected_claim\":\"Dropping fixed_release_slot preserves observation equality.\",\"witness\":{\"actions\":[{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false},{\"variant\":false,\"early\":true,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false}],\"observations\":[{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0},{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":0,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0}]},\"lesson\":\"Retain this control or discharge its exact observation obligation.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.DigitalTests.test_five_ablation_witnesses\"},{\"id\":\"NK-05\",\"claim_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"outcome\":\"REFUTED\",\"title\":\"Removing total fallback\",\"rejected_claim\":\"Dropping total_fallback preserves observation equality.\",\"witness\":{\"actions\":[{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false},{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":true,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false}],\"observations\":[{\"payload\":null,\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0},{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0}]},\"lesson\":\"Retain this control or discharge its exact observation obligation.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.DigitalTests.test_five_ablation_witnesses\"},{\"id\":\"NK-06\",\"claim_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"outcome\":\"REFUTED\",\"title\":\"Removing shared resource partition\",\"rejected_claim\":\"Dropping shared_resource_partition preserves observation equality.\",\"witness\":{\"actions\":[{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false},{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":true,\"network_signal\":false}],\"observations\":[{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0},{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":1,\"network_observation\":0}]},\"lesson\":\"Retain this control or discharge its exact observation obligation.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.DigitalTests.test_five_ablation_witnesses\"},{\"id\":\"NK-07\",\"claim_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"outcome\":\"REFUTED\",\"title\":\"Removing mediated egress\",\"rejected_claim\":\"Dropping mediated_egress preserves observation equality.\",\"witness\":{\"actions\":[{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false},{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":true}],\"observations\":[{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0},{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":1}]},\"lesson\":\"Retain this control or discharge its exact observation obligation.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.DigitalTests.test_five_ablation_witnesses\"}]", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:28:54Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:62d7418ce46c30167e6795ae61d34f033009d142fd0d3c53af6ddf2dd191e6d8", "id": "atom_727d6f1b647f40fd", "importance_score": 0.8, "metadata": { "actual_counterexample": true, "strategy": "Replay exact arithmetic or exhaustive digital action pairs; preserve both observations.", "tests": [ "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.DigitalTests.test_five_ablation_witnesses", "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.DigitalTests.test_five_ablation_witnesses", "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.DigitalTests.test_five_ablation_witnesses", "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.DigitalTests.test_five_ablation_witnesses", "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.DigitalTests.test_five_ablation_witnesses" ] }, "normalized_content": "[{\"id\":\"nk-03\",\"claim_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"outcome\":\"refuted\",\"title\":\"removing canonical encoding\",\"rejected_claim\":\"dropping canonical_encoding preserves observation equality.\",\"witness\":{\"actions\":[{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false},{\"variant\":true,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":true,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false}],\"observations\":[{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0},{\"payload\":[17,1],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0}]},\"lesson\":\"retain this control or discharge its exact observation obligation.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.digitaltests.test_five_ablation_witnesses\"},{\"id\":\"nk-04\",\"claim_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"outcome\":\"refuted\",\"title\":\"removing fixed release slot\",\"rejected_claim\":\"dropping fixed_release_slot preserves observation equality.\",\"witness\":{\"actions\":[{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false},{\"variant\":false,\"early\":true,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false}],\"observations\":[{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0},{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":0,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0}]},\"lesson\":\"retain this control or discharge its exact observation obligation.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.digitaltests.test_five_ablation_witnesses\"},{\"id\":\"nk-05\",\"claim_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"outcome\":\"refuted\",\"title\":\"removing total fallback\",\"rejected_claim\":\"dropping total_fallback preserves observation equality.\",\"witness\":{\"actions\":[{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false},{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":true,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false}],\"observations\":[{\"payload\":null,\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0},{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0}]},\"lesson\":\"retain this control or discharge its exact observation obligation.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.digitaltests.test_five_ablation_witnesses\"},{\"id\":\"nk-06\",\"claim_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"outcome\":\"refuted\",\"title\":\"removing shared resource partition\",\"rejected_claim\":\"dropping shared_resource_partition preserves observation equality.\",\"witness\":{\"actions\":[{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false},{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":true,\"network_signal\":false}],\"observations\":[{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0},{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":1,\"network_observation\":0}]},\"lesson\":\"retain this control or discharge its exact observation obligation.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.digitaltests.test_five_ablation_witnesses\"},{\"id\":\"nk-07\",\"claim_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"outcome\":\"refuted\",\"title\":\"removing mediated egress\",\"rejected_claim\":\"dropping mediated_egress preserves observation equality.\",\"witness\":{\"actions\":[{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false},{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":true}],\"observations\":[{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0},{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":1}]},\"lesson\":\"retain this control or discharge its exact observation obligation.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.digitaltests.test_five_ablation_witnesses\"}]", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 1, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [], "status": "REFUTED", "tags": [ "refutation" ], "type": "COUNTEREXAMPLE", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:28:54Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [], "confidence": null, "content": "[{\"id\":\"NK-08\",\"claim_id\":\"nominal_winner_robust\",\"outcome\":\"REFUTED\",\"title\":\"The certificate depends on the envelope\",\"rejected_claim\":\"The nominal winner remains certified under each tested perturbation.\",\"witness\":{\"disturbance_doubled\":{\"nominal_winner_radius\":\"3/50\",\"threshold\":\"11/200\",\"certificate_valid\":false},\"slower_cooling\":{\"nominal_winner_radius\":\"1/16\",\"threshold\":\"11/200\",\"certificate_valid\":false},\"load_bound_doubled\":{\"nominal_winner_radius\":\"9/100\",\"threshold\":\"11/200\",\"certificate_valid\":false}},\"lesson\":\"Re-synthesize after changing bounds. Certificate failure alone is not a physical exploit.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.ThermalTests.\"}]", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:28:57Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:7a98e21ad1315f60aeb8f08c16aa10bf5dc30fff738938f08e4fc89c88eba17a", "id": "atom_e0a3ada7028f4045", "importance_score": 0.8, "metadata": { "actual_counterexample": true, "strategy": "Replay exact arithmetic or exhaustive digital action pairs; preserve both observations.", "tests": [ "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.ThermalTests." ] }, "normalized_content": "[{\"id\":\"nk-08\",\"claim_id\":\"nominal_winner_robust\",\"outcome\":\"refuted\",\"title\":\"the certificate depends on the envelope\",\"rejected_claim\":\"the nominal winner remains certified under each tested perturbation.\",\"witness\":{\"disturbance_doubled\":{\"nominal_winner_radius\":\"3/50\",\"threshold\":\"11/200\",\"certificate_valid\":false},\"slower_cooling\":{\"nominal_winner_radius\":\"1/16\",\"threshold\":\"11/200\",\"certificate_valid\":false},\"load_bound_doubled\":{\"nominal_winner_radius\":\"9/100\",\"threshold\":\"11/200\",\"certificate_valid\":false}},\"lesson\":\"re-synthesize after changing bounds. certificate failure alone is not a physical exploit.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.thermaltests.\"}]", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 1, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [], "status": "REFUTED", "tags": [ "refutation" ], "type": "COUNTEREXAMPLE", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:28:57Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [], "confidence": null, "content": "[{\"id\":\"NK-09\",\"claim_id\":\"original_lean_compiles\",\"outcome\":\"REFUTED\",\"title\":\"Written proof source can fail to compile\",\"rejected_claim\":\"The unmodified archive compiles under Lean 4.19.0.\",\"witness\":{\"file\":\"Proofs.lean\",\"line\":185,\"exit_code\":1,\"log\":\"evidence/publication/lean-original-check.log\",\"archive_sha256\":\"c11a957a34bb0304165a6c6a4608fe137de766069037d1f8befcd50201ea5786\"},\"lesson\":\"The base case needed exact Nat.zero_le 50. Statements were preserved; current source passes.\",\"replay\":\"Extract the original archive to a temporary directory and run bash check_lean.sh with Lean 4.19.0.\",\"scope\":\"Historical compiler failure, not a mathematical counterexample.\"}]", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:29:00Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:c75cc1b45a017c5910181b7f7c33072c3117579e545e956e8d9c1100e667a213", "id": "atom_b74beaff2e044d8f", "importance_score": 0.8, "metadata": { "actual_counterexample": true, "strategy": "Compile the immutable original source with pinned Lean 4.19.0; retain exit 1 and the elaboration error.", "tests": [ "Extract the original archive to a temporary directory and run bash check_lean.sh with Lean 4.19.0." ] }, "normalized_content": "[{\"id\":\"nk-09\",\"claim_id\":\"original_lean_compiles\",\"outcome\":\"refuted\",\"title\":\"written proof source can fail to compile\",\"rejected_claim\":\"the unmodified archive compiles under lean 4.19.0.\",\"witness\":{\"file\":\"proofs.lean\",\"line\":185,\"exit_code\":1,\"log\":\"evidence/publication/lean-original-check.log\",\"archive_sha256\":\"c11a957a34bb0304165a6c6a4608fe137de766069037d1f8befcd50201ea5786\"},\"lesson\":\"the base case needed exact nat.zero_le 50. statements were preserved; current source passes.\",\"replay\":\"extract the original archive to a temporary directory and run bash check_lean.sh with lean 4.19.0.\",\"scope\":\"historical compiler failure, not a mathematical counterexample.\"}]", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 1, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [], "status": "REFUTED", "tags": [ "refutation" ], "type": "COUNTEREXAMPLE", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:29:00Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [], "confidence": null, "content": "Test invariant corner cases, gain 5 near-miss, raw observer distinction, and compile all-time invariant with arbitrary natural t.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:29:07Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:0fcee55a141fd218e9475bdce24dc48ec38d7e7a9d253186b72e972ea59cda8a", "id": "atom_b1f637235b874de4", "importance_score": 0.8, "metadata": { "actual_counterexample": false, "result": "No in-scope counterexample; weakened observation and gain assumptions have actual counterexamples elsewhere.", "strategy": "Test invariant corner cases, gain 5 near-miss, raw observer distinction, and compile all-time invariant with arbitrary natural t.", "tests": [ "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.ThermalTests", "bash check_lean.sh" ] }, "normalized_content": "test invariant corner cases, gain 5 near-miss, raw observer distinction, and compile all-time invariant with arbitrary natural t.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 1, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [], "status": "UNDER_TEST", "tags": [ "refutation" ], "type": "RISK", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:29:07Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [ "research/retrieval/formal-query.json", "research/retrieval/theoremsearch-receipts.json", "sha256:b701791f71b73d381f91d8aeb3042271fca1f984b762db99aacdc76a574b3c13" ], "confidence": null, "content": "Two TheoremSearch queries returned adjacent or low-signal results, none selected as a premise; the formal graph query timed out. Morph suggestions remained generic untrusted proposals. No formal-corpus coverage or new theorem is claimed.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:35:42Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:52bbad3a303ea47e7eb5c5fc355e06aacc00a5316b07230a846bc2cdeae44acd", "id": "retrieval_prior_art", "importance_score": 0.5, "metadata": {}, "normalized_content": "two theoremsearch queries returned adjacent or low-signal results, none selected as a premise; the formal graph query timed out. morph suggestions remained generic untrusted proposals. no formal-corpus coverage or new theorem is claimed.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.5, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [], "status": "CANDIDATE", "tags": [], "type": "RESULT", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:35:42Z" } ], "edges": [ { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:23:31Z", "edge_type": "REFUTES", "id": "edge_1b9e03c1f97240ab", "rationale": "Exact counterexample replay under the benchmark's default envelope.", "run_id": "", "source_atom_id": "atom_dfe2a077f1ac4711", "target_atom_id": "short_test_suffices", "weight": 1 }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:23:34Z", "edge_type": "DEPENDS_ON", "id": "edge_91c948a74ad044e2", "rationale": "The objective, integer domain and threshold semantics are declared model premises, not measured deployment facts.", "run_id": "", "source_atom_id": "optimal_cost", "target_atom_id": "model_contract", "weight": 1 }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:23:38Z", "edge_type": "TESTS", "id": "edge_3caccd4ca6864bda", "rationale": "Reject tampered cost 56, infeasible (7,1), and nonoptimal (8,0); independently enumerate every objective-bounded cheaper candidate; compile the global natural-number lower-bound theorem.", "run_id": "", "source_atom_id": "atom_6739535690954b3d", "target_atom_id": "optimal_cost", "weight": 1 }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:28:50Z", "edge_type": "REFUTES", "id": "edge_98466b33ea554406", "rationale": "Replay exact arithmetic or exhaustive digital action pairs; preserve both observations.", "run_id": "", "source_atom_id": "atom_29b01f19192e436b", "target_atom_id": "raw_sensor_safe", "weight": 1 }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:28:54Z", "edge_type": "REFUTES", "id": "edge_478bcd8cfa3d45b1", "rationale": "Replay exact arithmetic or exhaustive digital action pairs; preserve both observations.", "run_id": "", "source_atom_id": "atom_727d6f1b647f40fd", "target_atom_id": "digital_ablation_safe", "weight": 1 }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:28:57Z", "edge_type": "REFUTES", "id": "edge_1fa2b12009f44717", "rationale": "Replay exact arithmetic or exhaustive digital action pairs; preserve both observations.", "run_id": "", "source_atom_id": "atom_e0a3ada7028f4045", "target_atom_id": "nominal_winner_robust", "weight": 1 }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:29:00Z", "edge_type": "REFUTES", "id": "edge_64700d6da6744362", "rationale": "Compile the immutable original source with pinned Lean 4.19.0; retain exit 1 and the elaboration error.", "run_id": "", "source_atom_id": "atom_b74beaff2e044d8f", "target_atom_id": "original_lean_compiles", "weight": 1 }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:29:04Z", "edge_type": "DEPENDS_ON", "id": "edge_6b298d20a6ae4995", "rationale": "The integer recurrence and mediated threshold are declared premises; this claim does not imply a real-plant refinement.", "run_id": "", "source_atom_id": "integer_envelope", "target_atom_id": "model_contract", "weight": 1 }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:29:07Z", "edge_type": "TESTS", "id": "edge_5617d88c5bec4e0a", "rationale": "Test invariant corner cases, gain 5 near-miss, raw observer distinction, and compile all-time invariant with arbitrary natural t.", "run_id": "", "source_atom_id": "atom_b1f637235b874de4", "target_atom_id": "integer_envelope", "weight": 1 } ], "ok": true, "run_id": "" }, "latest_events": [ { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:35:42Z", "event_type": "evidence_attached", "id": 10371, "payload_json": "{\"artifact_hash\":\"sha256:b701791f71b73d381f91d8aeb3042271fca1f984b762db99aacdc76a574b3c13\",\"atom_id\":\"retrieval_prior_art\",\"evidence_id\":\"evidence_fc823f6c5e7042b5\",\"source_type\":\"theoremsearch_retrieval\"}" }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:35:42Z", "event_type": "atom_added", "id": 10370, "payload_json": "{\"atom_id\":\"retrieval_prior_art\",\"status\":\"CANDIDATE\",\"type\":\"RESULT\"}" }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:35:38Z", "event_type": "promotion_attempted", "id": 10369, "payload_json": "{\"claim_atom_id\":\"integer_envelope\",\"gate\":{\"diagnostics\":{\"counterexample_evidence\":[],\"evidence_with_provenance\":[\"evidence_58ed79e5dd194be3\",\"evidence_fccc959483944e37\"],\"evidence_without_provenance\":[],\"refuting_edges\":[]},\"has_claim_authority\":true,\"has_contradiction_search\":true,\"\":false,\"has_dependencies\":true,\"has_no_refuting_evidence\":true,\"has_promotion_rationale\":true,\"has_provenance\":true,\"has_refutation_attempt\":true,\"has_replay_recipe\":true,\"has_support_evidence\":true,\"has_supported_type\":true,\"input_checks\":{},\"missing\":[],\"ok\":true,\"target\":\"SUPPORTED\"},\"promotion_id\":\"promotion_268d7c89d3c34898\",\"to_status\":\"SUPPORTED\"}" }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:35:34Z", "event_type": "promotion_attempted", "id": 10368, "payload_json": "{\"claim_atom_id\":\"optimal_cost\",\"gate\":{\"diagnostics\":{\"counterexample_evidence\":[],\"evidence_with_provenance\":[\"evidence_15e6ee3eafdf4b72\",\"evidence_f6b07476b5b74db5\"],\"evidence_without_provenance\":[],\"refuting_edges\":[]},\"has_claim_authority\":true,\"has_contradiction_search\":true,\"\":false,\"has_dependencies\":true,\"has_no_refuting_evidence\":true,\"has_promotion_rationale\":true,\"has_provenance\":true,\"has_refutation_attempt\":true,\"has_replay_recipe\":true,\"has_support_evidence\":true,\"has_supported_type\":true,\"input_checks\":{},\"missing\":[],\"ok\":true,\"target\":\"SUPPORTED\"},\"promotion_id\":\"promotion_1e497465540f49a0\",\"to_status\":\"SUPPORTED\"}" }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:35:02Z", "event_type": "promotion_attempted", "id": 10367, "payload_json": "{\"claim_atom_id\":\"original_lean_compiles\",\"gate\":{\"diagnostics\":{\"counterexample_evidence\":[\"evidence_1cdffca330904107\"],\"evidence_with_provenance\":[\"evidence_1cdffca330904107\"],\"evidence_without_provenance\":[],\"refutation_hint\":\"SUPPORT promotion is blocked while counterexample evidence or REFUTES/CONTRADICTS edges exist.\",\"refuting_edges\":[\"edge_64700d6da6744362\"]},\"has_claim_authority\":true,\"has_contradiction_search\":false,\"\":true,\"has_dependencies\":false,\"has_no_refuting_evidence\":false,\"has_promotion_rationale\":true,\"has_provenance\":true,\"has_refutation_attempt\":true,\"has_replay_recipe\":true,\"has_support_evidence\":false,\"has_supported_type\":true,\"input_checks\":{},\"missing\":[],\"ok\":true,\"target\":\"REFUTED\"},\"promotion_id\":\"promotion_af8e73f1d61e4b76\",\"to_status\":\"REFUTED\"}" }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:59Z", "event_type": "evidence_attached", "id": 10366, "payload_json": "{\"artifact_hash\":\"sha256:72ebcbe72baaf6fd9896625ac7af14b0ebef6f0f436311215f222ac090aab31c\",\"atom_id\":\"original_lean_compiles\",\"evidence_id\":\"evidence_1cdffca330904107\",\"source_type\":\"counterexample\"}" }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:59Z", "event_type": "promotion_attempted", "id": 10365, "payload_json": "{\"claim_atom_id\":\"nominal_winner_robust\",\"gate\":{\"diagnostics\":{\"counterexample_evidence\":[\"evidence_3b3e32ab5c314d1c\"],\"evidence_with_provenance\":[\"evidence_3b3e32ab5c314d1c\"],\"evidence_without_provenance\":[],\"refutation_hint\":\"SUPPORT promotion is blocked while counterexample evidence or REFUTES/CONTRADICTS edges exist.\",\"refuting_edges\":[\"edge_1fa2b12009f44717\"]},\"has_claim_authority\":true,\"has_contradiction_search\":false,\"\":true,\"has_dependencies\":false,\"has_no_refuting_evidence\":false,\"has_promotion_rationale\":true,\"has_provenance\":true,\"has_refutation_attempt\":true,\"has_replay_recipe\":true,\"has_support_evidence\":false,\"has_supported_type\":true,\"input_checks\":{},\"missing\":[],\"ok\":true,\"target\":\"REFUTED\"},\"promotion_id\":\"promotion_a9e330258cda4185\",\"to_status\":\"REFUTED\"}" }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:56Z", "event_type": "evidence_attached", "id": 10364, "payload_json": "{\"artifact_hash\":\"sha256:800bb7000f2323bc34e0ee25d9fcef774e66e338841e3b02ae6874025edfff46\",\"atom_id\":\"nominal_winner_robust\",\"evidence_id\":\"evidence_3b3e32ab5c314d1c\",\"source_type\":\"counterexample\"}" }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:56Z", "event_type": "promotion_attempted", "id": 10363, "payload_json": "{\"claim_atom_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"gate\":{\"diagnostics\":{\"counterexample_evidence\":[\"evidence_9f6fc19597ec483c\"],\"evidence_with_provenance\":[\"evidence_9f6fc19597ec483c\"],\"evidence_without_provenance\":[],\"refutation_hint\":\"SUPPORT promotion is blocked while counterexample evidence or REFUTES/CONTRADICTS edges exist.\",\"refuting_edges\":[\"edge_478bcd8cfa3d45b1\"]},\"has_claim_authority\":true,\"has_contradiction_search\":false,\"\":true,\"has_dependencies\":false,\"has_no_refuting_evidence\":false,\"has_promotion_rationale\":true,\"has_provenance\":true,\"has_refutation_attempt\":true,\"has_replay_recipe\":true,\"has_support_evidence\":false,\"has_supported_type\":true,\"input_checks\":{},\"missing\":[],\"ok\":true,\"target\":\"REFUTED\"},\"promotion_id\":\"promotion_95fd1285409f4c85\",\"to_status\":\"REFUTED\"}" }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:52Z", "event_type": "evidence_attached", "id": 10362, "payload_json": "{\"artifact_hash\":\"sha256:20fac2eb8c82d3ea54537909be6cbd0ed539db9d3ba317f99cea5af601f73267\",\"atom_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"evidence_id\":\"evidence_9f6fc19597ec483c\",\"source_type\":\"counterexample\"}" }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:52Z", "event_type": "promotion_attempted", "id": 10361, "payload_json": "{\"claim_atom_id\":\"raw_sensor_safe\",\"gate\":{\"diagnostics\":{\"counterexample_evidence\":[\"evidence_6718616398c34e09\"],\"evidence_with_provenance\":[\"evidence_6718616398c34e09\"],\"evidence_without_provenance\":[],\"refutation_hint\":\"SUPPORT promotion is blocked while counterexample evidence or REFUTES/CONTRADICTS edges exist.\",\"refuting_edges\":[\"edge_98466b33ea554406\"]},\"has_claim_authority\":true,\"has_contradiction_search\":false,\"\":true,\"has_dependencies\":false,\"has_no_refuting_evidence\":false,\"has_promotion_rationale\":true,\"has_provenance\":true,\"has_refutation_attempt\":true,\"has_replay_recipe\":true,\"has_support_evidence\":false,\"has_supported_type\":true,\"input_checks\":{},\"missing\":[],\"ok\":true,\"target\":\"REFUTED\"},\"promotion_id\":\"promotion_7f6df2678457408a\",\"to_status\":\"REFUTED\"}" }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:48Z", "event_type": "evidence_attached", "id": 10360, "payload_json": "{\"artifact_hash\":\"sha256:61c1878e806b6ed2c160a820d3a44552216f34bc55dfb7dee08f963e5c1a1fd5\",\"atom_id\":\"raw_sensor_safe\",\"evidence_id\":\"evidence_6718616398c34e09\",\"source_type\":\"counterexample\"}" }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:48Z", "event_type": "promotion_attempted", "id": 10359, "payload_json": "{\"claim_atom_id\":\"short_test_suffices\",\"gate\":{\"diagnostics\":{\"counterexample_evidence\":[\"evidence_5a3ae8998fac471c\"],\"evidence_with_provenance\":[\"evidence_5a3ae8998fac471c\"],\"evidence_without_provenance\":[],\"refutation_hint\":\"SUPPORT promotion is blocked while counterexample evidence or REFUTES/CONTRADICTS edges exist.\",\"refuting_edges\":[\"edge_1b9e03c1f97240ab\"]},\"has_claim_authority\":true,\"has_contradiction_search\":false,\"\":true,\"has_dependencies\":false,\"has_no_refuting_evidence\":false,\"has_promotion_rationale\":true,\"has_provenance\":true,\"has_refutation_attempt\":true,\"has_replay_recipe\":true,\"has_support_evidence\":false,\"has_supported_type\":true,\"input_checks\":{},\"missing\":[],\"ok\":true,\"target\":\"REFUTED\"},\"promotion_id\":\"promotion_e14c81e453634f35\",\"to_status\":\"REFUTED\"}" }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:44Z", "event_type": "evidence_attached", "id": 10358, "payload_json": "{\"artifact_hash\":\"sha256:5faba2d40d54ddb5fc6219d947cf3357f4499d04d67cc63c95bae775c955f8bf\",\"atom_id\":\"short_test_suffices\",\"evidence_id\":\"evidence_5a3ae8998fac471c\",\"source_type\":\"counterexample\"}" }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:29Z", "event_type": "evidence_attached", "id": 10357, "payload_json": "{\"artifact_hash\":\"sha256:3719a1d940bc3b5b3bd8405e8f237228d8360152f9c1c1458c3bf8cc8942ef05\",\"atom_id\":\"integer_envelope\",\"evidence_id\":\"evidence_fccc959483944e37\",\"source_type\":\"contradiction_search\"}" }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:29Z", "event_type": "evidence_attached", "id": 10356, "payload_json": "{\"artifact_hash\":\"sha256:3719a1d940bc3b5b3bd8405e8f237228d8360152f9c1c1458c3bf8cc8942ef05\",\"atom_id\":\"optimal_cost\",\"evidence_id\":\"evidence_f6b07476b5b74db5\",\"source_type\":\"contradiction_search\"}" }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:07Z", "event_type": "promotion_attempted", "id": 10355, "payload_json": "{\"claim_atom_id\":\"original_lean_compiles\",\"gate\":{\"diagnostics\":{\"counterexample_evidence\":[],\"evidence_with_provenance\":[],\"evidence_without_provenance\":[],\"provenance_hint\":\"Attach at least one evidence record with source_uri, artifact_path, or artifact_text before promoting to SUPPORTED or REFUTED.\",\"refutation_hint\":\"SUPPORT promotion is blocked while counterexample evidence or REFUTES/CONTRADICTS edges exist.\",\"refuting_edges\":[\"edge_64700d6da6744362\"]},\"has_claim_authority\":true,\"has_contradiction_search\":false,\"\":true,\"has_dependencies\":false,\"has_no_refuting_evidence\":false,\"has_promotion_rationale\":true,\"has_provenance\":false,\"has_refutation_attempt\":true,\"has_replay_recipe\":true,\"has_support_evidence\":false,\"has_supported_type\":true,\"input_checks\":{},\"missing\":[\"has_provenance\"],\"ok\":false,\"target\":\"REFUTED\"},\"promotion_id\":\"promotion_9df03f5225564de8\",\"to_status\":\"REFUTED\"}" }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:03Z", "event_type": "promotion_attempted", "id": 10354, "payload_json": "{\"claim_atom_id\":\"nominal_winner_robust\",\"gate\":{\"diagnostics\":{\"counterexample_evidence\":[],\"evidence_with_provenance\":[],\"evidence_without_provenance\":[],\"provenance_hint\":\"Attach at least one evidence record with source_uri, artifact_path, or artifact_text before promoting to SUPPORTED or REFUTED.\",\"refutation_hint\":\"SUPPORT promotion is blocked while counterexample evidence or REFUTES/CONTRADICTS edges exist.\",\"refuting_edges\":[\"edge_1fa2b12009f44717\"]},\"has_claim_authority\":true,\"has_contradiction_search\":false,\"\":true,\"has_dependencies\":false,\"has_no_refuting_evidence\":false,\"has_promotion_rationale\":true,\"has_provenance\":false,\"has_refutation_attempt\":true,\"has_replay_recipe\":true,\"has_support_evidence\":false,\"has_supported_type\":true,\"input_checks\":{},\"missing\":[\"has_provenance\"],\"ok\":false,\"target\":\"REFUTED\"},\"promotion_id\":\"promotion_99ed0ab1ba904344\",\"to_status\":\"REFUTED\"}" }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:00Z", "event_type": "promotion_attempted", "id": 10353, "payload_json": "{\"claim_atom_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"gate\":{\"diagnostics\":{\"counterexample_evidence\":[],\"evidence_with_provenance\":[],\"evidence_without_provenance\":[],\"provenance_hint\":\"Attach at least one evidence record with source_uri, artifact_path, or artifact_text before promoting to SUPPORTED or REFUTED.\",\"refutation_hint\":\"SUPPORT promotion is blocked while counterexample evidence or REFUTES/CONTRADICTS edges exist.\",\"refuting_edges\":[\"edge_478bcd8cfa3d45b1\"]},\"has_claim_authority\":true,\"has_contradiction_search\":false,\"\":true,\"has_dependencies\":false,\"has_no_refuting_evidence\":false,\"has_promotion_rationale\":true,\"has_provenance\":false,\"has_refutation_attempt\":true,\"has_replay_recipe\":true,\"has_support_evidence\":false,\"has_supported_type\":true,\"input_checks\":{},\"missing\":[\"has_provenance\"],\"ok\":false,\"target\":\"REFUTED\"},\"promotion_id\":\"promotion_356b5100ac6546cf\",\"to_status\":\"REFUTED\"}" }, { "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:33:54Z", "event_type": "promotion_attempted", "id": 10352, "payload_json": "{\"claim_atom_id\":\"raw_sensor_safe\",\"gate\":{\"diagnostics\":{\"counterexample_evidence\":[],\"evidence_with_provenance\":[],\"evidence_without_provenance\":[],\"provenance_hint\":\"Attach at least one evidence record with source_uri, artifact_path, or artifact_text before promoting to SUPPORTED or REFUTED.\",\"refutation_hint\":\"SUPPORT promotion is blocked while counterexample evidence or REFUTES/CONTRADICTS edges exist.\",\"refuting_edges\":[\"edge_98466b33ea554406\"]},\"has_claim_authority\":true,\"has_contradiction_search\":false,\"\":true,\"has_dependencies\":false,\"has_no_refuting_evidence\":false,\"has_promotion_rationale\":true,\"has_provenance\":false,\"has_refutation_attempt\":true,\"has_replay_recipe\":true,\"has_support_evidence\":false,\"has_supported_type\":true,\"input_checks\":{},\"missing\":[\"has_provenance\"],\"ok\":false,\"target\":\"REFUTED\"},\"promotion_id\":\"promotion_9a64d2467ccf433c\",\"to_status\":\"REFUTED\"}" } ], "non_claims": [ "Research Kernel stores public artifacts and evidence, not hidden chain-of-thought.", "SUPPORTED means the local promotion gate passed; it is not an external proof by itself.", "Morph reformulations are candidate search objects until separately tested." ], "ok": true, "refuted_claims": [ { "artifact_refs": [ "CONTRACTS.md", "MATH.md", "Proofs.lean", "results.json", "sha256:5faba2d40d54ddb5fc6219d947cf3357f4499d04d67cc63c95bae775c955f8bf" ], "confidence": null, "content": "For the default s=7,r=1 setting, identical observations for the first 23 steps imply all-time identical observations.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:17:35Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:217229595c2619247beeee75fd4f10cc55ff77364ea88cebc9720ab1c1c3bd4a", "id": "short_test_suffices", "importance_score": 0.5, "metadata": { "publication_scope": "bounded illustrative research", "replay_recipe": "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab; bash check_lean.sh" }, "normalized_content": "for the default s=7,r=1 setting, identical observations for the first 23 steps imply all-time identical observations.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.5, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [ "https://github.com/TheDarkLightX/CovertChannelLab/blob/main/research/negative-knowledge.json" ], "status": "REFUTED", "tags": [ "covert-channel-lab", "negative-knowledge", "publication" ], "type": "HYPOTHESIS", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:48Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [ "CONTRACTS.md", "MATH.md", "Proofs.lean", "results.json", "sha256:61c1878e806b6ed2c160a820d3a44552216f34bc55dfb7dee08f963e5c1a1fd5" ], "confidence": null, "content": "For the default s=7,r=2 setting, the receiver can observe raw temperatures without distinguishing u=0 from u=1 under common disturbance.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:17:38Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:3aafea5df0b272f3136ea2b715be53abab8a328107cad07f9b943eb7f24de962", "id": "raw_sensor_safe", "importance_score": 0.5, "metadata": { "publication_scope": "bounded illustrative research", "replay_recipe": "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab; bash check_lean.sh" }, "normalized_content": "for the default s=7,r=2 setting, the receiver can observe raw temperatures without distinguishing u=0 from u=1 under common disturbance.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.5, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [ "https://github.com/TheDarkLightX/CovertChannelLab/blob/main/research/negative-knowledge.json" ], "status": "REFUTED", "tags": [ "covert-channel-lab", "negative-knowledge", "publication" ], "type": "HYPOTHESIS", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:52Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [ "CONTRACTS.md", "MATH.md", "Proofs.lean", "results.json", "sha256:20fac2eb8c82d3ea54537909be6cbd0ed539db9d3ba317f99cea5af601f73267" ], "confidence": null, "content": "Within the five-control model, at least one digital control can be removed while preserving observations for every untrusted action.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:17:41Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:fabcff14e0362b2db67a7ad778280bf141917501db345356d25ffba1c1e900d9", "id": "digital_ablation_safe", "importance_score": 0.5, "metadata": { "publication_scope": "bounded illustrative research", "replay_recipe": "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab; bash check_lean.sh" }, "normalized_content": "within the five-control model, at least one digital control can be removed while preserving observations for every untrusted action.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.5, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [ "https://github.com/TheDarkLightX/CovertChannelLab/blob/main/research/negative-knowledge.json" ], "status": "REFUTED", "tags": [ "covert-channel-lab", "negative-knowledge", "publication" ], "type": "HYPOTHESIS", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:56Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [ "CONTRACTS.md", "MATH.md", "Proofs.lean", "results.json", "sha256:800bb7000f2323bc34e0ee25d9fcef774e66e338841e3b02ae6874025edfff46" ], "confidence": null, "content": "The nominal s=7,r=2 invariant certificate remains valid when the disturbance doubles, load bound doubles, or rho increases to 0.92.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:17:44Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:99f614563771cd03b092543b35f0b2d6c45b1eae4314cb5087308b3250ff5cdf", "id": "nominal_winner_robust", "importance_score": 0.5, "metadata": { "publication_scope": "bounded illustrative research", "replay_recipe": "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab; bash check_lean.sh" }, "normalized_content": "the nominal s=7,r=2 invariant certificate remains valid when the disturbance doubles, load bound doubles, or rho increases to 0.92.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.5, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [ "https://github.com/TheDarkLightX/CovertChannelLab/blob/main/research/negative-knowledge.json" ], "status": "REFUTED", "tags": [ "covert-channel-lab", "negative-knowledge", "publication" ], "type": "HYPOTHESIS", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:34:59Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [ "CONTRACTS.md", "MATH.md", "Proofs.lean", "results.json", "sha256:72ebcbe72baaf6fd9896625ac7af14b0ebef6f0f436311215f222ac090aab31c" ], "confidence": null, "content": "The unmodified Proofs.lean in the original archive compiles successfully under pinned Lean 4.19.0.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:17:48Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:acf187ddc8ccf72df9491e5a96dd7393e4c43e0fc4857908e92d75a4c0eeb073", "id": "original_lean_compiles", "importance_score": 0.5, "metadata": { "publication_scope": "bounded illustrative research", "replay_recipe": "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab; bash check_lean.sh" }, "normalized_content": "the unmodified proofs.lean in the original archive compiles successfully under pinned lean 4.19.0.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.5, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [ "https://github.com/TheDarkLightX/CovertChannelLab/blob/main/research/negative-knowledge.json" ], "status": "REFUTED", "tags": [ "covert-channel-lab", "negative-knowledge", "publication" ], "type": "HYPOTHESIS", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:35:02Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [], "confidence": null, "content": "{\"first_different_step\":24,\"zero_trace\":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0],\"hot_trace\":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,1],\"zero_temperature\":\"920233556923127490136639/100000000000000000000000000\",\"hot_temperature\":\"2760700670769382470409917/50000000000000000000000000\",\"common_disturbance\":\"1/1000\"}", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:23:31Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:9dd8ca2e865c681c0cfb0e2c282ce044e6574980754c2649b4dcfb7b6e2b8d4d", "id": "atom_dfe2a077f1ac4711", "importance_score": 0.8, "metadata": { "actual_counterexample": true, "evidence": "research/negative-knowledge.json", "lesson": "Use an all-time invariant. This near-miss first diverges at step 24.", "record_id": "NK-01", "strategy": "Exact counterexample replay under the benchmark's default envelope.", "tests": [ "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.ThermalTests.test_near_miss_at_24_not_23" ] }, "normalized_content": "{\"first_different_step\":24,\"zero_trace\":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0],\"hot_trace\":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,1],\"zero_temperature\":\"920233556923127490136639/100000000000000000000000000\",\"hot_temperature\":\"2760700670769382470409917/50000000000000000000000000\",\"common_disturbance\":\"1/1000\"}", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 1, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [], "status": "REFUTED", "tags": [ "refutation" ], "type": "COUNTEREXAMPLE", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:23:31Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [], "confidence": null, "content": "[{\"id\":\"NK-02\",\"claim_id\":\"raw_sensor_safe\",\"outcome\":\"REFUTED\",\"title\":\"Raw sensors defeat the observation restriction\",\"rejected_claim\":\"The winner makes raw hot and quiet temperatures indistinguishable.\",\"witness\":{\"s\":7,\"r\":2,\"step\":1,\"quiet_temperature\":\"1/1000\",\"hot_temperature\":\"1/200\",\"quantized_observations\":[0,0]},\"lesson\":\"The guarantee depends on a mediated quantized observer; raw trajectories differ.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.ThermalTests.test_quantization_is_essential\"}]", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:28:50Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:7728f1f2b382ebac2e5614581b04e3ba109f7e04b6976b406b21def8b4c96847", "id": "atom_29b01f19192e436b", "importance_score": 0.8, "metadata": { "actual_counterexample": true, "strategy": "Replay exact arithmetic or exhaustive digital action pairs; preserve both observations.", "tests": [ "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.ThermalTests.test_quantization_is_essential" ] }, "normalized_content": "[{\"id\":\"nk-02\",\"claim_id\":\"raw_sensor_safe\",\"outcome\":\"refuted\",\"title\":\"raw sensors defeat the observation restriction\",\"rejected_claim\":\"the winner makes raw hot and quiet temperatures indistinguishable.\",\"witness\":{\"s\":7,\"r\":2,\"step\":1,\"quiet_temperature\":\"1/1000\",\"hot_temperature\":\"1/200\",\"quantized_observations\":[0,0]},\"lesson\":\"the guarantee depends on a mediated quantized observer; raw trajectories differ.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.thermaltests.test_quantization_is_essential\"}]", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 1, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [], "status": "REFUTED", "tags": [ "refutation" ], "type": "COUNTEREXAMPLE", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:28:50Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [], "confidence": null, "content": "[{\"id\":\"NK-03\",\"claim_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"outcome\":\"REFUTED\",\"title\":\"Removing canonical encoding\",\"rejected_claim\":\"Dropping canonical_encoding preserves observation equality.\",\"witness\":{\"actions\":[{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false},{\"variant\":true,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":true,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false}],\"observations\":[{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0},{\"payload\":[17,1],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0}]},\"lesson\":\"Retain this control or discharge its exact observation obligation.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.DigitalTests.test_five_ablation_witnesses\"},{\"id\":\"NK-04\",\"claim_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"outcome\":\"REFUTED\",\"title\":\"Removing fixed release slot\",\"rejected_claim\":\"Dropping fixed_release_slot preserves observation equality.\",\"witness\":{\"actions\":[{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false},{\"variant\":false,\"early\":true,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false}],\"observations\":[{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0},{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":0,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0}]},\"lesson\":\"Retain this control or discharge its exact observation obligation.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.DigitalTests.test_five_ablation_witnesses\"},{\"id\":\"NK-05\",\"claim_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"outcome\":\"REFUTED\",\"title\":\"Removing total fallback\",\"rejected_claim\":\"Dropping total_fallback preserves observation equality.\",\"witness\":{\"actions\":[{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false},{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":true,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false}],\"observations\":[{\"payload\":null,\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0},{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0}]},\"lesson\":\"Retain this control or discharge its exact observation obligation.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.DigitalTests.test_five_ablation_witnesses\"},{\"id\":\"NK-06\",\"claim_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"outcome\":\"REFUTED\",\"title\":\"Removing shared resource partition\",\"rejected_claim\":\"Dropping shared_resource_partition preserves observation equality.\",\"witness\":{\"actions\":[{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false},{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":true,\"network_signal\":false}],\"observations\":[{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0},{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":1,\"network_observation\":0}]},\"lesson\":\"Retain this control or discharge its exact observation obligation.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.DigitalTests.test_five_ablation_witnesses\"},{\"id\":\"NK-07\",\"claim_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"outcome\":\"REFUTED\",\"title\":\"Removing mediated egress\",\"rejected_claim\":\"Dropping mediated_egress preserves observation equality.\",\"witness\":{\"actions\":[{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false},{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":true}],\"observations\":[{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0},{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":1}]},\"lesson\":\"Retain this control or discharge its exact observation obligation.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.DigitalTests.test_five_ablation_witnesses\"}]", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:28:54Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:62d7418ce46c30167e6795ae61d34f033009d142fd0d3c53af6ddf2dd191e6d8", "id": "atom_727d6f1b647f40fd", "importance_score": 0.8, "metadata": { "actual_counterexample": true, "strategy": "Replay exact arithmetic or exhaustive digital action pairs; preserve both observations.", "tests": [ "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.DigitalTests.test_five_ablation_witnesses", "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.DigitalTests.test_five_ablation_witnesses", "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.DigitalTests.test_five_ablation_witnesses", "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.DigitalTests.test_five_ablation_witnesses", "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.DigitalTests.test_five_ablation_witnesses" ] }, "normalized_content": "[{\"id\":\"nk-03\",\"claim_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"outcome\":\"refuted\",\"title\":\"removing canonical encoding\",\"rejected_claim\":\"dropping canonical_encoding preserves observation equality.\",\"witness\":{\"actions\":[{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false},{\"variant\":true,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":true,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false}],\"observations\":[{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0},{\"payload\":[17,1],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0}]},\"lesson\":\"retain this control or discharge its exact observation obligation.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.digitaltests.test_five_ablation_witnesses\"},{\"id\":\"nk-04\",\"claim_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"outcome\":\"refuted\",\"title\":\"removing fixed release slot\",\"rejected_claim\":\"dropping fixed_release_slot preserves observation equality.\",\"witness\":{\"actions\":[{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false},{\"variant\":false,\"early\":true,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false}],\"observations\":[{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0},{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":0,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0}]},\"lesson\":\"retain this control or discharge its exact observation obligation.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.digitaltests.test_five_ablation_witnesses\"},{\"id\":\"nk-05\",\"claim_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"outcome\":\"refuted\",\"title\":\"removing total fallback\",\"rejected_claim\":\"dropping total_fallback preserves observation equality.\",\"witness\":{\"actions\":[{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false},{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":true,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false}],\"observations\":[{\"payload\":null,\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0},{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0}]},\"lesson\":\"retain this control or discharge its exact observation obligation.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.digitaltests.test_five_ablation_witnesses\"},{\"id\":\"nk-06\",\"claim_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"outcome\":\"refuted\",\"title\":\"removing shared resource partition\",\"rejected_claim\":\"dropping shared_resource_partition preserves observation equality.\",\"witness\":{\"actions\":[{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false},{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":true,\"network_signal\":false}],\"observations\":[{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0},{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":1,\"network_observation\":0}]},\"lesson\":\"retain this control or discharge its exact observation obligation.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.digitaltests.test_five_ablation_witnesses\"},{\"id\":\"nk-07\",\"claim_id\":\"digital_ablation_safe\",\"outcome\":\"refuted\",\"title\":\"removing mediated egress\",\"rejected_claim\":\"dropping mediated_egress preserves observation equality.\",\"witness\":{\"actions\":[{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":false},{\"variant\":false,\"early\":false,\"succeeds\":false,\"shared_signal\":false,\"network_signal\":true}],\"observations\":[{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":0},{\"payload\":[17,0],\"release_slot\":1,\"shared_observation\":0,\"network_observation\":1}]},\"lesson\":\"retain this control or discharge its exact observation obligation.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.digitaltests.test_five_ablation_witnesses\"}]", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 1, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [], "status": "REFUTED", "tags": [ "refutation" ], "type": "COUNTEREXAMPLE", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:28:54Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [], "confidence": null, "content": "[{\"id\":\"NK-08\",\"claim_id\":\"nominal_winner_robust\",\"outcome\":\"REFUTED\",\"title\":\"The certificate depends on the envelope\",\"rejected_claim\":\"The nominal winner remains certified under each tested perturbation.\",\"witness\":{\"disturbance_doubled\":{\"nominal_winner_radius\":\"3/50\",\"threshold\":\"11/200\",\"certificate_valid\":false},\"slower_cooling\":{\"nominal_winner_radius\":\"1/16\",\"threshold\":\"11/200\",\"certificate_valid\":false},\"load_bound_doubled\":{\"nominal_winner_radius\":\"9/100\",\"threshold\":\"11/200\",\"certificate_valid\":false}},\"lesson\":\"Re-synthesize after changing bounds. Certificate failure alone is not a physical exploit.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.ThermalTests.\"}]", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:28:57Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:7a98e21ad1315f60aeb8f08c16aa10bf5dc30fff738938f08e4fc89c88eba17a", "id": "atom_e0a3ada7028f4045", "importance_score": 0.8, "metadata": { "actual_counterexample": true, "strategy": "Replay exact arithmetic or exhaustive digital action pairs; preserve both observations.", "tests": [ "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.ThermalTests." ] }, "normalized_content": "[{\"id\":\"nk-08\",\"claim_id\":\"nominal_winner_robust\",\"outcome\":\"refuted\",\"title\":\"the certificate depends on the envelope\",\"rejected_claim\":\"the nominal winner remains certified under each tested perturbation.\",\"witness\":{\"disturbance_doubled\":{\"nominal_winner_radius\":\"3/50\",\"threshold\":\"11/200\",\"certificate_valid\":false},\"slower_cooling\":{\"nominal_winner_radius\":\"1/16\",\"threshold\":\"11/200\",\"certificate_valid\":false},\"load_bound_doubled\":{\"nominal_winner_radius\":\"9/100\",\"threshold\":\"11/200\",\"certificate_valid\":false}},\"lesson\":\"re-synthesize after changing bounds. certificate failure alone is not a physical exploit.\",\"replay\":\"python3 -m unittest -v test_lab.thermaltests.\"}]", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 1, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [], "status": "REFUTED", "tags": [ "refutation" ], "type": "COUNTEREXAMPLE", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:28:57Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [], "confidence": null, "content": "[{\"id\":\"NK-09\",\"claim_id\":\"original_lean_compiles\",\"outcome\":\"REFUTED\",\"title\":\"Written proof source can fail to compile\",\"rejected_claim\":\"The unmodified archive compiles under Lean 4.19.0.\",\"witness\":{\"file\":\"Proofs.lean\",\"line\":185,\"exit_code\":1,\"log\":\"evidence/publication/lean-original-check.log\",\"archive_sha256\":\"c11a957a34bb0304165a6c6a4608fe137de766069037d1f8befcd50201ea5786\"},\"lesson\":\"The base case needed exact Nat.zero_le 50. Statements were preserved; current source passes.\",\"replay\":\"Extract the original archive to a temporary directory and run bash check_lean.sh with Lean 4.19.0.\",\"scope\":\"Historical compiler failure, not a mathematical counterexample.\"}]", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:29:00Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:c75cc1b45a017c5910181b7f7c33072c3117579e545e956e8d9c1100e667a213", "id": "atom_b74beaff2e044d8f", "importance_score": 0.8, "metadata": { "actual_counterexample": true, "strategy": "Compile the immutable original source with pinned Lean 4.19.0; retain exit 1 and the elaboration error.", "tests": [ "Extract the original archive to a temporary directory and run bash check_lean.sh with Lean 4.19.0." ] }, "normalized_content": "[{\"id\":\"nk-09\",\"claim_id\":\"original_lean_compiles\",\"outcome\":\"refuted\",\"title\":\"written proof source can fail to compile\",\"rejected_claim\":\"the unmodified archive compiles under lean 4.19.0.\",\"witness\":{\"file\":\"proofs.lean\",\"line\":185,\"exit_code\":1,\"log\":\"evidence/publication/lean-original-check.log\",\"archive_sha256\":\"c11a957a34bb0304165a6c6a4608fe137de766069037d1f8befcd50201ea5786\"},\"lesson\":\"the base case needed exact nat.zero_le 50. statements were preserved; current source passes.\",\"replay\":\"extract the original archive to a temporary directory and run bash check_lean.sh with lean 4.19.0.\",\"scope\":\"historical compiler failure, not a mathematical counterexample.\"}]", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 1, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [], "status": "REFUTED", "tags": [ "refutation" ], "type": "COUNTEREXAMPLE", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:29:00Z" } ], "schema": "research_kernel/report/v1", "summary": { "counts_by_status": { "CANDIDATE": 8, "REFUTED": 10, "SUPPORTED": 2, "UNDER_TEST": 2 }, "counts_by_type": { "CLAIM": 2, "COUNTEREXAMPLE": 5, "HYPOTHESIS": 5, "QUESTION": 3, "REFORMULATION": 2, "RESULT": 2, "RISK": 3 }, "edge_count": 9, "event_count": 68, "evidence_count": 10, "ok": true, "run": { "budget": { "campaign": "bounded publication audit", "new_experiments": "replay existing results plus one statement-preserving Lean base-case repair", "retrieval_queries": 3 }, "constraints": { "authority": "Research Kernel statuses do not confer proof, deployment authority, or hardware qualification", "non_claims": [ "physical containment", "physical-model refinement", "complete real observer inventory", "general bounded-deadline AI fallback", "OpenAI endorsement" ], "scope": "Five binary digital controls; integer s and r; declared thermal envelope and mediated quantized observations" }, "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:15:56Z", "goal": "Publish the supplied illustrative digital and thermal configuration model, preserve exact results and useful negative knowledge, and leave a replayable research handoff. No hardware security or unrestricted AI containment claim.", "id": "", "metadata": { "domain": "formal methods and bounded information-flow research", "repository": "https://github.com/TheDarkLightX/CovertChannelLab", "source_bundle": "evidence/original/covert_channel_lab.zip" }, "status": "ACTIVE", "success_criteria": "Python replay and all 34 tests pass; Lean 4.19.0 source checks without sorryAx; negative controls and limitations have replay recipes; research graph and takeover guide are exported; GitHub repository and Pages deployment are verified.", "title": "Covert Channel Lab: reproducible publication and negative knowledge", "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:15:56Z" } }, "supported_claims": [ { "artifact_refs": [ "CONTRACTS.md", "MATH.md", "Proofs.lean", "results.json", "sha256:3719a1d940bc3b5b3bd8405e8f237228d8360152f9c1c1458c3bf8cc8942ef05", "sha256:c7fac7d4d6ddd4ad8b9e6bffac4e83b996d6d04b7a50ac8b3721a2e5d42e560b" ], "confidence": null, "content": "Under the declared integer model with 2s+r>=16 and r<=4, all feasible designs cost at least 57, attained by s=7,r=2. Falsifier: a feasible pair with cost<57, invalid identity coefficients, or failed Lean theorem.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:17:28Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:1807b0b8569010a2ac1fc23b220fefcb1bf95abc865b65464519a04d10b36072", "id": "optimal_cost", "importance_score": 0.5, "metadata": { "publication_scope": "bounded illustrative research", "replay_recipe": "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab; bash check_lean.sh" }, "normalized_content": "under the declared integer model with 2s+r>=16 and r<=4, all feasible designs cost at least 57, attained by s=7,r=2. falsifier: a feasible pair with cost<57, invalid identity coefficients, or failed lean theorem.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.5, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [ "https://github.com/TheDarkLightX/CovertChannelLab/blob/main/evidence/publication/verification.json" ], "status": "SUPPORTED", "tags": [ "covert-channel-lab", "negative-knowledge", "publication" ], "type": "CLAIM", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:35:34Z" }, { "artifact_refs": [ "CONTRACTS.md", "MATH.md", "Proofs.lean", "results.json", "sha256:3719a1d940bc3b5b3bd8405e8f237228d8360152f9c1c1458c3bf8cc8942ef05", "sha256:c7fac7d4d6ddd4ad8b9e6bffac4e83b996d6d04b7a50ac8b3721a2e5d42e560b" ], "confidence": null, "content": "For all natural t, the stipulated integer envelope at s=7,r=2 stays below 55. Falsifier: any recurrence step violating M<=50 or a failed winning_envelope_forever theorem. Real-plant refinement is a separate open obligation.", "created_at": "2026-09-18T11:17:32Z", "evidence_score": 0, "hash": "sha256:9e042af7824abf904447003150f04e0d3f1ea5c29386b3164cc5e94f2fd05d19", "id": "integer_envelope", "importance_score": 0.5, "metadata": { "publication_scope": "bounded illustrative research", "replay_recipe": "python3 -m unittest -v test_lab; bash check_lean.sh" }, "normalized_content": "for all natural t, the stipulated integer envelope at s=7,r=2 stays below 55. falsifier: any recurrence step violating m<=50 or a failed winning_envelope_forever theorem. real-plant refinement is a separate open obligation.", "novelty_score": 0.5, "parent_ids": [], "refutability_score": 0.5, "run_id": "", "source_refs": [ "https://github.com/TheDarkLightX/CovertChannelLab/blob/main/Proofs.lean" ], "status": "SUPPORTED", "tags": [ "covert-channel-lab", "negative-knowledge", "publication" ], "type": "CLAIM", "uncertainty_score": 0.5, "updated_at": "2026-09-18T11:35:38Z" } ] }